The power of belonging

The power of belonging - photograph of a piece of sandpaper - the explanation is in the articleOur desire for belonging can change the world (for good and for ill)…

It’s safer to be in a group than outside of it, hence the drive to “belong” has existed in people for as long as we’ve been social animals.

In civil society we tend to use the term “belonging” for when we talk about community building or our own people and teams. But we rarely see it for what it could be: an extraordinarily powerful strategic lever for social change.

With community building, the reason is obvious: belonging is what drives social cohesion, ownership, and the agency to create change.

With teams, it’s because it is central to psychological safety, which underpins both team performance and its ability to learn and grow.

In sessions with teams, I’ll often introduce the “five levels of psychological safety”: that it’s OK for me to be here; to contribute; to ask questions; to challenge the consensus; to admit I was wrong or screwed up.

The foundation of all five is a sense of belonging. Which also is why “here’s why you belong” is the first step in the feedback process I recommend to clients for their most difficult performance conversations.

Belonging is an incredibly powerful motivator. For good, but also for ill.

The author and historian C S Lewis spoke about the latter in a lecture he once gave at King’s College, London, which he subsequently turned into a powerful essay (the full text of which you can find here).

His central message, first for those students and then for the wider world, was that our desire to belong, if not carefully handled, is what turns good people into scoundrels.

The essay was published in 1944, but it might have been penned last week considering its relevance to the ongoing soap opera that is “sandpaper gate”.

For those not in the know, in 2018, the Australian cricket team toured South Africa and were caught using sandpaper to tamper with the ball. Three players were banned for a year, but the rest were cleared, found to have no knowledge or involvement.

That is, until two weeks ago when Uzman Khawaja, of one of the “innocents”, published his autobiography. In it, he acknowledged he knew full well what was happening, but more than that, the entire team and most of the staff knew, and many were actively complicit. Other retired players have since corroborated his story.

The problem is, some of that team still play for Australia, having maintained their innocence throughout. One of them is now Australia’s captain.

Cameron Bancroft was the player caught with the sandpaper and one of the three who took the fall. Last week he responded with his own account, supporting the book’s claim and elaborating, not just on what happened, but more importantly, why.

Here’s what Bancroft, then a young man new into the test squad, says of himself:

“I was asked whether I could carry out the task. I felt uncomfortable and compromised. I knew it was wrong… It was cheating. But I also saw an opportunity to contribute… I just wanted to be accepted by my teammates beyond the runs and catches I took. This was an opportunity for that.

“That desire to belong clouded my judgment.”

If C S Lewis had ever needed a case study, Bancroft’s tale is it.

Why am I telling you all this?

Because as Lewis pointed out, we all want to belong, and the people we most want to belong with are the people who will most shape our moral judgment.

It’s why Bancroft used sandpaper. It’s why wannabe tech-bros are now sporting leather jackets and petitioning for Nvidia to reinstate Jensen Huang.

It’s why GOP politicians are prepared to tie themselves in pretzel-like knots on TV talk shows, and why Oxford and Birmingham have had to pursue court cases to stop people tying flags to lampposts.

Almost every charity’s vision statement, to be actually realised, requires some form of change in public attitudes or political policy, or both.

So, it follows that if we want the public and the politicians to value civil society, to embrace its moral principles, to support its mission for change, the single best way to achieve that, is for them to feel they belong, with us.

Hence, the true power of volunteering is not in the hands that it provides for us, or even in the service those hands carry out. It’s in the sense of belonging it inculcates, and the values and moral judgement it transfers as a result.

So, how seriously are you taking volunteers and their sense of belonging as a route to social change?

Sign up here for articles and event invitations

* indicates required
Share this article with a friend

Stay up to date with our latest!

* indicates required